FOXBOROUGH, Massachusetts, June 27. Manuel Neuer has dismissed suggestions he was at fault for Ecuador’s second goal in Germany’s 3-1 defeat, insisting his positioning was correct despite mounting criticism of the legendary goalkeeper’s performance.
Germany’s final group stage loss has reignited debate over Julian Nagelsmann’s decision to start Neuer ahead of Oliver Baumann, who had established himself as the national team’s number one over the past year. The 40 year old’s error on Ecuador’s second goal has prompted uncomfortable questions about whether Germany can rely on the once invincible shot stopper in the knockout stages.
Neuer defends his positioning
Confronted by a reporter about the mistake, Neuer offered a robust defence of his actions.
“No. Because it’s a perfectly normal headed flick on, and I’m just trying to catch the ball. It’s a completely normal situation,” Neuer said “Any goalkeeper who has ever played the game knows that I have to position myself like that for the ball, and that I have to try and catch it exactly like that. There’s a header, and you try to get to the ball. Of course, it looks unfortunate because I’m standing right there, but it wasn’t a mistake on my part.”
The Bayern Munich veteran dismissed suggestions he could have acted differently. “Well, how else am I supposed to stand there? Am I supposed to dive even though the ball is coming straight at me? I have to move towards the ball and try to catch it. If someone puts a foot in and it flies past me, then it flies past me. But I have to position myself like that. There’s no other option. I can’t just evaporate.”
Growing concerns over Neuer’s form
While Jonathan Tah’s positioning for the goal was also questionable, the incident has intensified scrutiny on Neuer’s continued status as Germany’s first choice goalkeeper. The 2014 World Cup winner, now 40, has shown glimpses of his vintage form but has also become increasingly prone to errors.
Critics argue that Nagelsmann’s loyalty to Neuer undermines Baumann, who has performed admirably when called upon. The Hoffenheim goalkeeper, 34, had been Germany’s starter for much of the past 12 months and was widely expected to retain the role for the tournament.
Germany’s knockout dilemma
With a Round of 32 clash against Paraguay looming on Monday, Nagelsmann faces a difficult decision. Stick with Neuer, whose experience and presence remain formidable, or turn to Baumann, who has earned the trust of many within the squad.
Germany’s attacking output, nine goals in three group matches suggests they possess the firepower to progress deep into the tournament. But defensive frailties, particularly in goal, could prove their undoing. For all Neuer’s protestations, the footage of Ecuador’s second goal does not make for comfortable viewing. Germany’s hopes may depend on whether their coach can make the difficult call.
